Court rules Malaysia hotels cannot use service charge to prop up minimum wage

Sunday, 24 Mar, 2021 0

A landmark ruling in a Malaysia court could have wide-ranging implications for the hotel and restaurant industry in the country.

A judge ruled that hotels cannot use the 10% service charge paid by customers to bolster staff pay up to the mandatory minimum wage.

"Service charge, being monies collected from third parties, does not belong to the hotel. When it is paid by a customer as part of the bill, ownership in those monies does not vest in, or transfer to the hotel," Judge Datuk Nallini Pathmanathan said in summary.

"Ownership of the monies is immediately transferred and lies with the employees who are eligible to receive those monies."

"It follows that as the monies did not, at any point in time, belong to the hotel, there is no entitlement in law for the hotel to appropriate and utilise those monies to meet the statutory obligation created by the National Wages Council Consultative Act," Nallini added.

The judgment came in an appeal case between Crystal Crown Hotel and Resort and the National Union of Hotel, Bar & Restaurant Workers.

Industry leaders have said it could have major repercussions for the industry.

TravelMole Editorial Team

Editor for TravelMole North America and Asia pacific regions. Ray is a highly experienced (15+ years) skilled journalist and editor predominantly in travel, hospitality and lifestyle working with a huge number of major market-leading brands. He has also cover in-depth news, interviews and features in general business, finance, tech and geopolitical issues for a select few major news outlets and publishers.

Queensland – where it’s rude not to stare Here in Queensland, there’s plenty to do. But there’s even more to...

Virtuoso is the leading global network of agencies specializing in luxury and experiential travel, with more than 20,000 advisors. We...

In 2024, The Red Sea will be ready to welcome 300,000 guests in line with the completion of 16 hotels...

We work with reliable data providers with global coverage, that guarantee data representativeness as well as compliance with International Personal...

Since its launch in 1999, TravelMole.com has become, one of the largest global online travel industry communities. It is comprised...

City Cruises is a leading operator of sightseeing, dining and charter services operating in London, York and Poole. We offer...

The Polish Tourism Organisation (Polska Organizacja Turystyczna – POT) is one of several dozen national tourism organisations operating in the...

Celebrating its 30-year anniversary in 2022, Regent Seven Seas Cruises® offers guests An Unrivaled Experience® with every luxury included. Carrying...

Global Hotel Alliance brings together a unique collection of independent hospitality brands for GHA DISCOVERY, a multi-brand loyalty programme. GHA...

Jet2.com is the UK’s third largest airline, flying from ten UK airports to more than 60 destinations across Europe and beyond....

Ensuring our guests have an unforgettable experience while sailing with us is paramount; however, your health and safety remains our...

Greater Fort Lauderdale’s assortment of adventures awaits you. Whether you want to relax on the beach as the sound of...

Chargebacks911 offers scalable solutions that are customized for any business of any size in any industry. With the flexibility to...

For over 18 years and over 106 completed events, the Travel & Adventure Show has connected over 2.5 million travel...

Traveltek is the world-leading provider of online solutions for the travel trade, from consumer-facing websites to call centre applications. We...

MGM Resorts International (NYSE: MGM) is an S&P 500® global entertainment company with national and international locations featuring best-in-class hotels...