Judge quashes cruise passenger’s USD21.5 million award

Sunday, 07 Jan, 2016 0

A judge in Seattle has thrown out a $21.5 million award to a cruise passenger who claimed serious injury after being hit by a sliding door on a Holland America round the world cruise.

A jury awarded James R. Hausman the compensation late last year but US District Judge Barbara Rothstein has ordered a retrial after deciding Hausman’s story contained ‘grave inconsistencies’.

Hausman’s former personal assistant came forward after the trial to say he had deleted emails that could have compromised his case.

Hausman sued Seattle-based Holland America Line in 2013 after being struck by a sliding door claiming he suffered from dizziness and seizures as a result.

However, his personal assistant Amy Mizeur gave post-trial testimony stating her former boss deleted emails that should have been passed to the Holland America legal team before the trial.

Rothstein found enough credibility in Mizeur’s story to quash the original verdict and order a retrial.

Speaking of Hausman’s testimony at the original trial, Rothstein wrote: "As a witness, he came across evasive and untrustworthy. He appeared to weigh each answer, not for its truthfulness, but to assess whether it would damage his case. Mr Hausman also seemed to capitalize on his alleged brain injury when it was convenient for him."

The judge said some emails which were recovered ‘cast doubt on his veracity’.

By deleting emails, Hausman ‘substantially interfered with defendants’ ability to fully and fairly prepare for and proceed to trial’.

No date has been set for a retrial.

below social share icons

Linsey McNeill

Editor Linsey McNeill has been writing about travel for more than three decades. Bylines include The Times, Telegraph, Observer, Guardian and Which? plus the South China Morning Post. She also shares insider tips on thetraveljournalist.co.uk

Family-owned Olympic Holidays has been arranging holidays to Greece, the Greek islands and Cyprus for more than half century. The company is unrivalled...

SAINT LUCIA IS NO ORDINARY ISLAND Equal parts beauty and mystique, Saint Lucia captivates anyone who sets foot on her...

Since 1932, P&O Cruises has offered Aussies and Kiwis the opportunity to take to the seas and have the holiday...

Our Mission Ecommerce has transformative powers, and we believe everyone should be able to take part. But outdated solutions and...

Hilton is a leading global hospitality company with a portfolio of 22 world-class brands comprising nearly 7,300 properties and more than 1.1 million rooms, in...

Atout France guides and supports the French regions with their development strategy and helps set up investment projects in order...

To say Sweden is fit for a fairy tale is not overstating it—the palaces dazzle, the boreal forests are brimming...

The superpower in bed banks for 30 years We are an award-winning and trusted accommodation wholesaler since 1991. We are...

The Detroit Metro Convention & Visitors Bureau (DMCVB) is the only organization that promotes metro Detroit regionally, nationally and...

Located in the Mediterranean and connecting Asia and European continents that are separated by the famous Bosphorus, Türkiye is a...

Cunard is the operator of luxury cruise ships Queen Mary 2®, Queen Victoria® and Queen Elizabeth®. Renowned for impeccable White...

Princess Hotels & Resorts is a hotel chain specialising in holiday and urban hotels located in first class tourist destinations,...

The Oregon Tourism Commission, dba Travel Oregon, works to enhance visitors’ experiences by providing information, resources and trip planning tools...