Knee defender branded ‘dangerous and provocative’

The battle lines are being drawn over the use of the controversial “knee defender” device, which prevents passengers from reclining their seats during flights. The device, which costs around USD10, prevents the seat in front of a passenger from being pushed back by jamming it in the upright position. The Daily Express reports that the device has become “hugely popular” in the United States, despite the fact that it has been banned by some airlines. The newspaper quotes Tom Hamilton, a spokesman for the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA), which has branded the device “dangerous and provocative”. He reportedly said: “This could hinder exit from a seat in any emergency situation. We are also concerned that it mighty provoke disputes among passengers and lead to an increase in disruptive behaviour on-board aircraft.” The Express canvassed British Airways, Virgin Atlantic and EasyJet over the device; all three carriers allow its use even if BA says it is “not something we would actively encourage”. What do you think? Is the knee defender an ingenious invention to be welcomed by carriers and travellers? Or is it bound to lead to more “air rage” incidents? Post your comments below …